Friday, November 20, 2026
Fighting to protect key Welsh wildlife
Nation Cymru reports that a UK-wide wildlife protection organisation has written to Minister Llŷr Gruffydd MS, warning that sidelining independent science and withholding key evidence ahead of an announcement on badger culling could trigger a judicial review.
The news website says that Protect the Wild has formally warned the Welsh Government that it is considering seeking legal advice regarding a potential judicial review if ministers introduce or expand badger culling in Wales through a flawed decision-making process:
In a formal letter sent to Minister Llŷr Gruffydd MS, the organisation raised serious concerns over transparency, procedural fairness, and the Welsh Government’s failure to properly scrutinise independent scientific evidence ahead of an anticipated ministerial statement on bovine TB policy on 24 November.
The intervention comes as over 28,000 people have backed a petition calling on the Welsh Government to reject Reform UK’s motion to consider a targeted badger cull to ‘manage’ bovine TB
Opposition to the prospect of badger culling in Wales has grown steadily following the passing of a Reform UK motion in the Senedd on 15 July 2026, by votes of 79 in favour to 9 against, to consider a targeted badger cull to manage bovine TB.
In response, activist and environmental campaigner Sarah Reisz launched the petition ‘We call upon the Senedd to reject any badger cull in Wales’.
Published on 21 July 2026, it managed to achieve the 10,000 signatures required to be considered for a Senedd debate in just five days, such is the strong opposition to a cull – with many Plaid supporters angry at supporting their historic election win while England abandons its own badger cull.
On 18 September 2026, independent scientists, including Professor Paul Torgerson, Professor of Veterinary Epidemiology at the University of Zurich, and independent scientist Tom Langton, met with senior Welsh Government officials to highlight major flaws in the evidence used to justify badger culling. Experts raised critical concerns regarding the interpretation of historic intervention studies, the limitations of existing cattle testing, and the role of undetected infections within cattle herds.
Following the meeting, a detailed proposal was submitted for an all-day scientific workshop bringing together Welsh Government officials, the Technical Advisory Group (TAG), the Bovine TB Eradication Programme Board, the Animal and Plant Health Agency (APHA), and independent experts to rigorously examine competing scientific interpretations before recommendations were finalised.
However, the Welsh Government declined to take the workshop forward, suggesting instead that further engagement should wait until a possible public consultation.
On 23 October 2026, officials confirmed they had received the Programme Board’s policy paper and were considering its recommendations, but stated that neither the Programme Board paper nor supporting TAG papers would be published until the Minister makes his official statement.
Protect the Wild warns that withholding crucial scientific advice while policy recommendations are being drafted denies the public and independent experts any meaningful opportunity to scrutinise the evidence before ministers settle on a course of action.
If ministers move to kill thousands of legally protected wild animals without transparency, lawful scrutiny, or a genuine public consultation, Protect the Wild is prepared to seek formal legal advice on a judicial review.
Plaid Cymru's record on this issue is very poor. There is a real danger that the government will push for a cull without a transparent process that properly considers all the evidence. If they do this then legal action will certainly be justified.
The news website says that Protect the Wild has formally warned the Welsh Government that it is considering seeking legal advice regarding a potential judicial review if ministers introduce or expand badger culling in Wales through a flawed decision-making process:
In a formal letter sent to Minister Llŷr Gruffydd MS, the organisation raised serious concerns over transparency, procedural fairness, and the Welsh Government’s failure to properly scrutinise independent scientific evidence ahead of an anticipated ministerial statement on bovine TB policy on 24 November.
The intervention comes as over 28,000 people have backed a petition calling on the Welsh Government to reject Reform UK’s motion to consider a targeted badger cull to ‘manage’ bovine TB
Opposition to the prospect of badger culling in Wales has grown steadily following the passing of a Reform UK motion in the Senedd on 15 July 2026, by votes of 79 in favour to 9 against, to consider a targeted badger cull to manage bovine TB.
In response, activist and environmental campaigner Sarah Reisz launched the petition ‘We call upon the Senedd to reject any badger cull in Wales’.
Published on 21 July 2026, it managed to achieve the 10,000 signatures required to be considered for a Senedd debate in just five days, such is the strong opposition to a cull – with many Plaid supporters angry at supporting their historic election win while England abandons its own badger cull.
On 18 September 2026, independent scientists, including Professor Paul Torgerson, Professor of Veterinary Epidemiology at the University of Zurich, and independent scientist Tom Langton, met with senior Welsh Government officials to highlight major flaws in the evidence used to justify badger culling. Experts raised critical concerns regarding the interpretation of historic intervention studies, the limitations of existing cattle testing, and the role of undetected infections within cattle herds.
Following the meeting, a detailed proposal was submitted for an all-day scientific workshop bringing together Welsh Government officials, the Technical Advisory Group (TAG), the Bovine TB Eradication Programme Board, the Animal and Plant Health Agency (APHA), and independent experts to rigorously examine competing scientific interpretations before recommendations were finalised.
However, the Welsh Government declined to take the workshop forward, suggesting instead that further engagement should wait until a possible public consultation.
On 23 October 2026, officials confirmed they had received the Programme Board’s policy paper and were considering its recommendations, but stated that neither the Programme Board paper nor supporting TAG papers would be published until the Minister makes his official statement.
Protect the Wild warns that withholding crucial scientific advice while policy recommendations are being drafted denies the public and independent experts any meaningful opportunity to scrutinise the evidence before ministers settle on a course of action.
If ministers move to kill thousands of legally protected wild animals without transparency, lawful scrutiny, or a genuine public consultation, Protect the Wild is prepared to seek formal legal advice on a judicial review.
Plaid Cymru's record on this issue is very poor. There is a real danger that the government will push for a cull without a transparent process that properly considers all the evidence. If they do this then legal action will certainly be justified.
Thursday, November 19, 2026
What is the future of Wales' four police forces?
Nation Cymru reports that Wales’s four police forces face a shake-up under UK Government plans to create about 200 local policing commands across England and Wales.
They add that Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood said each would have a named commander, with boundaries broadly aligned with council areas, but she did not say how many commands Wales would have or what would happen to its existing force boundaries:
The announcement came on the day the chief constables of North Wales, Dyfed-Powys, South Wales and Gwent were due to give evidence to the Commons Welsh Affairs Committee. MPs are examining how proposed force mergers and the abolition of police and crime commissioners would affect Wales.
The Home Office says the commands would focus on offences such as burglary, vehicle and phone theft, and antisocial behaviour. Aligning them more closely with council boundaries is intended to help police work with probation, health and housing services.
In Wales, health, housing and local government are devolved, while policing remains reserved to Westminster.
The Home Office says a “local police guarantee” would set standards for each command. Larger regional forces would provide specialist capabilities such as firearms, forensics and public order policing, and investigate serious and complex crime. The number of regional forces has yet to be announced.
A new National Police Service would take on counter-terrorism, some fraud and serious organised crime, the police air service and roads policing. The Home Office says cutting duplication across the current 43 force headquarters could free up thousands of officers for neighbourhood policing.
Ms Mahmood said a timetable would be set out once the Police Reform Bill had been laid before Parliament in the spring. She said operational responsibilities would only move to the National Police Service once it was ready.
“Public safety comes first, and I don’t want to do it too quickly, such that you see a drop-off in service for communities,” she said.
The Home Office plans to abolish police and crime commissioners when their terms end in May 2028. In England, elected mayors or council leaders would take on oversight through new policing boards.
Wales has no equivalent elected regional mayors, and the Home Office says it will work with the Welsh Government and councils on arrangements for Wales.
Wales’s four commissioners have proposed an all-Wales partnership board and four regional boards based on the existing force areas. Senedd Research says a Wales-specific system could give Welsh institutions a greater role in oversight while responsibility for policing remains at Westminster.
The Welsh Government is seeking the devolution of policing and justice.
Reorganising public bodies is always disruptive and expensive, but the case for a single Welsh police force coupled with devolving responsibility for policing to the Welsh government is quite strong. The last thing we need is another regional board to oversee the existing forces. That has already been tried with local councils and the experiment has failed.
These boards are toothless and unaccountable. Such a solution is a cop-out, adopted because Welsh ministers have been too afraid to take tough decisions and have been unable to take local politicians with them.
They add that Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood said each would have a named commander, with boundaries broadly aligned with council areas, but she did not say how many commands Wales would have or what would happen to its existing force boundaries:
The announcement came on the day the chief constables of North Wales, Dyfed-Powys, South Wales and Gwent were due to give evidence to the Commons Welsh Affairs Committee. MPs are examining how proposed force mergers and the abolition of police and crime commissioners would affect Wales.
The Home Office says the commands would focus on offences such as burglary, vehicle and phone theft, and antisocial behaviour. Aligning them more closely with council boundaries is intended to help police work with probation, health and housing services.
In Wales, health, housing and local government are devolved, while policing remains reserved to Westminster.
The Home Office says a “local police guarantee” would set standards for each command. Larger regional forces would provide specialist capabilities such as firearms, forensics and public order policing, and investigate serious and complex crime. The number of regional forces has yet to be announced.
A new National Police Service would take on counter-terrorism, some fraud and serious organised crime, the police air service and roads policing. The Home Office says cutting duplication across the current 43 force headquarters could free up thousands of officers for neighbourhood policing.
Ms Mahmood said a timetable would be set out once the Police Reform Bill had been laid before Parliament in the spring. She said operational responsibilities would only move to the National Police Service once it was ready.
“Public safety comes first, and I don’t want to do it too quickly, such that you see a drop-off in service for communities,” she said.
The Home Office plans to abolish police and crime commissioners when their terms end in May 2028. In England, elected mayors or council leaders would take on oversight through new policing boards.
Wales has no equivalent elected regional mayors, and the Home Office says it will work with the Welsh Government and councils on arrangements for Wales.
Wales’s four commissioners have proposed an all-Wales partnership board and four regional boards based on the existing force areas. Senedd Research says a Wales-specific system could give Welsh institutions a greater role in oversight while responsibility for policing remains at Westminster.
The Welsh Government is seeking the devolution of policing and justice.
Reorganising public bodies is always disruptive and expensive, but the case for a single Welsh police force coupled with devolving responsibility for policing to the Welsh government is quite strong. The last thing we need is another regional board to oversee the existing forces. That has already been tried with local councils and the experiment has failed.
These boards are toothless and unaccountable. Such a solution is a cop-out, adopted because Welsh ministers have been too afraid to take tough decisions and have been unable to take local politicians with them.
Wednesday, November 18, 2026
Deadlock in the Senedd?
Nation Cymru reports that Reform’s Senedd group has failed to attend yet another Plenary session while continuing to collect their salaries.
They add that the party’s Welsh leader Helen Jenner said in a statement “meaningful debate and scrutiny” could not take place in Wales until the Senedd’s Llywydd U-turned on his decision to block a Reform MS from speaking. That, though, is not likely to happen:
Presiding Officer Huw Irranca-Davies ordered Joe Martin to apologise last week after he made remarks about immigrants that were condemned as “unnecessarily provocative and deliberately offensive”.
Martin had claimed differing birth rates and mass immigration would make white British people a minority by 2063.
Concerns were raised that Martin was echoing the far-right “Great Replacement” conspiracy theory which claims white populations in Western countries are being systematically replaced by non-white immigrants.
Reform and the Llywydd now remain locked in a standoff – with Martin refusing to apologise for the remarks and the Presiding Officer refusing to call on him to speak until he does.
On Tuesdays in the Senedd, Members have the opportunity to grill Wales’ First Minister, with leaders of opposition parties given the chance to question him directly on matters of government policy.
However, all Reform MSs withdrew the questions they had submitted for this morning’s (November 17) First Minister’s Questions session.
Jenner issued a statement saying: “Following discussions with the Llywydd about the importance of freedom of speech, we remain dissatisfied with the progress made.
“For this reason, Reform UK Members will NOT be returning to the Senedd Chamber today.
“Meaningful debate and scrutiny cannot take place unless elected Members are free to express their views without fear of censorship.
“We will continue to work tirelessly on behalf of our constituents while seeking further discussions with the Llywydd and exploring all options available to us.”
Reform began boycotting Senedd proceedings last Wednesday in solidarity with Martin after the Llywydd gave him an ultimatum over his remarks.
The walkout meant the group missed their own debate calling for more support for the armed forces and veterans.
It is understood that some Reform Members with links to the armed forces were unhappy with the decision to boycott proceedings.
Despite missing key Senedd sessions, backbench Reform MSs will continue to receive their full annual salary of £79,817 – while Jenner will retain her full £124,713 salary as the leader of the opposition.
It is understood that Irranca-Davies is not likely to change his position on the matter of Martin’s speaking ban.
Reform's decision to continue their boycott means that they missed First Minister's questions and the draft budget statement yesterday. In fact, while the Senedd was sitting, Reform’s leader in Wales and other senior Senedd Members were drinking in a Cardiff Bay pub. Today they have tabled a motion in support of freedom of speech but now look unlikely to be present to move it.
Both sides in this dispute look unmoveable. In my view the Presiding Officer should stick to his guns, which will mean that Reform MSs are being paid tens of thousands of pounds but not doing their job.
Update: it is rumoured that Reform UK MSs will indeed come into the Senedd siambr today to debate their own motion on freedom of speech. I would hope that if they do then they will support the cross party amendment:
Notes that free speech is a fundamental right that carries duties and responsibilities, and that it must be exercised within the law, including legal protections against speech which incites hatred or harm, threatens the rights or safety of others, or causes fear of violence, alarm or distress.
Further notes that there is a requirement on Members of the Senedd to act within the bounds of Standing Order 13.9 and paragraph 193 of the Llywydd's guidance on the proper conduct of business, and that Members should conduct their Senedd business and duties in a way that upholds the principles of dignity and respect for all.
Further Update: Reform failed to show again and withdrew their motion
They add that the party’s Welsh leader Helen Jenner said in a statement “meaningful debate and scrutiny” could not take place in Wales until the Senedd’s Llywydd U-turned on his decision to block a Reform MS from speaking. That, though, is not likely to happen:
Presiding Officer Huw Irranca-Davies ordered Joe Martin to apologise last week after he made remarks about immigrants that were condemned as “unnecessarily provocative and deliberately offensive”.
Martin had claimed differing birth rates and mass immigration would make white British people a minority by 2063.
Concerns were raised that Martin was echoing the far-right “Great Replacement” conspiracy theory which claims white populations in Western countries are being systematically replaced by non-white immigrants.
Reform and the Llywydd now remain locked in a standoff – with Martin refusing to apologise for the remarks and the Presiding Officer refusing to call on him to speak until he does.
On Tuesdays in the Senedd, Members have the opportunity to grill Wales’ First Minister, with leaders of opposition parties given the chance to question him directly on matters of government policy.
However, all Reform MSs withdrew the questions they had submitted for this morning’s (November 17) First Minister’s Questions session.
Jenner issued a statement saying: “Following discussions with the Llywydd about the importance of freedom of speech, we remain dissatisfied with the progress made.
“For this reason, Reform UK Members will NOT be returning to the Senedd Chamber today.
“Meaningful debate and scrutiny cannot take place unless elected Members are free to express their views without fear of censorship.
“We will continue to work tirelessly on behalf of our constituents while seeking further discussions with the Llywydd and exploring all options available to us.”
Reform began boycotting Senedd proceedings last Wednesday in solidarity with Martin after the Llywydd gave him an ultimatum over his remarks.
The walkout meant the group missed their own debate calling for more support for the armed forces and veterans.
It is understood that some Reform Members with links to the armed forces were unhappy with the decision to boycott proceedings.
Despite missing key Senedd sessions, backbench Reform MSs will continue to receive their full annual salary of £79,817 – while Jenner will retain her full £124,713 salary as the leader of the opposition.
It is understood that Irranca-Davies is not likely to change his position on the matter of Martin’s speaking ban.
Reform's decision to continue their boycott means that they missed First Minister's questions and the draft budget statement yesterday. In fact, while the Senedd was sitting, Reform’s leader in Wales and other senior Senedd Members were drinking in a Cardiff Bay pub. Today they have tabled a motion in support of freedom of speech but now look unlikely to be present to move it.
Both sides in this dispute look unmoveable. In my view the Presiding Officer should stick to his guns, which will mean that Reform MSs are being paid tens of thousands of pounds but not doing their job.
Update: it is rumoured that Reform UK MSs will indeed come into the Senedd siambr today to debate their own motion on freedom of speech. I would hope that if they do then they will support the cross party amendment:
Notes that free speech is a fundamental right that carries duties and responsibilities, and that it must be exercised within the law, including legal protections against speech which incites hatred or harm, threatens the rights or safety of others, or causes fear of violence, alarm or distress.
Further notes that there is a requirement on Members of the Senedd to act within the bounds of Standing Order 13.9 and paragraph 193 of the Llywydd's guidance on the proper conduct of business, and that Members should conduct their Senedd business and duties in a way that upholds the principles of dignity and respect for all.
Further Update: Reform failed to show again and withdrew their motion
Tuesday, November 17, 2026
Correcting the Brexit failure
The Independent reports that Andy Burnham has hit out at Boris Johnson’s Brexit deal ahead of his highly anticipated EU summit this week, as he argues the UK has “lost more than we gained” following the 2016 referendum.
The paper says that in a speech on Monday, the prime minister will compare the UK’s Brexit deal to “the Emperor’s new clothes – where no one is prepared to say the obvious truth”:
His intervention comes days before the prime minister will travel to Brussels for the UK-EU summit, where he is expected to sign new agreements in an effort to reset relations with the bloc.
Mr Burnham has set out a bold approach to relations with the EU since entering Downing Street, but will lay out three tests for any revised agreements, including sticking to Labour’s manifesto red lines, which prevent deals on free movement, or rejoining the EU, customs union or single market.
Speaking at the Lord Mayor’s Banquet on Monday evening, he will argue that Britain cannot afford to turn away from the bloc, and that the world has fundamentally changed since Britain voted to leave in 2016.
In a speech on Monday, the prime minister will compare Brexit to ‘the Emperor’s new clothes – where no one is prepared to say the obvious truth’ (Getty) “It’s like the Emperor’s new clothes – where no one is prepared to say the obvious truth. Well, I say it as I see it,” he will say.
“And to be frank, the Emperor has nothing on. The Brexit we were given has not worked. We have lost more than we gained.”
Hitting out at Boris Johnson’s Brexit deal, he will say the settlement has not delivered what voters were promised.
The prime minister will commit to signing an agreement if it meets three tests, including being within Labour’s red lines, bringing Brexit closer to what people thought they were voting for in 2016, and passing his “Makerfield test” by delivering “tangible improvements in people’s everyday lives”.
He is expected to say: “And look – the point is that this is a win-win.
“It illustrates our new approach. Not adversarial. No longer burning bridges. But being constructive and positive – showing that we can come together to confront shared challenges.”
The prime minister is due to meet EU leaders in Brussels this week and sign agreements that he says could raise GDP by 0.4 per cent – including on food and farming, emissions trading and a youth mobility scheme.
I understand that Burnham has to move carefully on this but at last there is a Prime Minister who recognises the problem and is talking about putting it right.
The paper says that in a speech on Monday, the prime minister will compare the UK’s Brexit deal to “the Emperor’s new clothes – where no one is prepared to say the obvious truth”:
His intervention comes days before the prime minister will travel to Brussels for the UK-EU summit, where he is expected to sign new agreements in an effort to reset relations with the bloc.
Mr Burnham has set out a bold approach to relations with the EU since entering Downing Street, but will lay out three tests for any revised agreements, including sticking to Labour’s manifesto red lines, which prevent deals on free movement, or rejoining the EU, customs union or single market.
Speaking at the Lord Mayor’s Banquet on Monday evening, he will argue that Britain cannot afford to turn away from the bloc, and that the world has fundamentally changed since Britain voted to leave in 2016.
In a speech on Monday, the prime minister will compare Brexit to ‘the Emperor’s new clothes – where no one is prepared to say the obvious truth’ (Getty) “It’s like the Emperor’s new clothes – where no one is prepared to say the obvious truth. Well, I say it as I see it,” he will say.
“And to be frank, the Emperor has nothing on. The Brexit we were given has not worked. We have lost more than we gained.”
Hitting out at Boris Johnson’s Brexit deal, he will say the settlement has not delivered what voters were promised.
The prime minister will commit to signing an agreement if it meets three tests, including being within Labour’s red lines, bringing Brexit closer to what people thought they were voting for in 2016, and passing his “Makerfield test” by delivering “tangible improvements in people’s everyday lives”.
He is expected to say: “And look – the point is that this is a win-win.
“It illustrates our new approach. Not adversarial. No longer burning bridges. But being constructive and positive – showing that we can come together to confront shared challenges.”
The prime minister is due to meet EU leaders in Brussels this week and sign agreements that he says could raise GDP by 0.4 per cent – including on food and farming, emissions trading and a youth mobility scheme.
I understand that Burnham has to move carefully on this but at last there is a Prime Minister who recognises the problem and is talking about putting it right.
Monday, November 16, 2026
Tougher action needed to enforce fox hunting ban
The Mirror reports that animal rights campaigners have demanded stronger laws after more than 100 foxes were chased by hunts across England and Wales this autumn.
The paper says that despite a ban on fox hunting, new figures reveal 104 foxes were chased by hunts during fox cub hunting season:
Cub hunting takes place between August and the end of October and sees hunts surrounding fox habitats and setting their hounds on them to train the dogs how to hunt and kill.
Compiled by animal welfare charity the League Against Cruel Sports, the figures come from incidents reported into its confidential Animal Crimewatch service, evidence obtained by its field operatives, and from reports by hunt saboteurs and hunt monitors.
As well as the hunting of foxes, the data also showed 332 reports of hunts wreaking havoc with anti-social behaviour. The figures are only from hunts being monitored, meaning the true figure of foxes hunted could be even higher.
Emma Slawinski, chief executive of the League Against Cruel Sports, said: “The brutal practice of cub hunting is still happening despite the fox hunting ban and we need stronger hunting laws to end it once and for all.
“We need the government to act upon its pledge to ban so-called trail hunting and finish the job by introducing legislation in the next parliamentary session at the latest that will consign fox hunting to the history books.
“We also need an effective deterrent in the form of tougher penalties, the removal of all the loopholes in the Hunting Act, and the law changed so that hunts cannot claim their kills are ‘accidental’.”
Labour MP Ruth Jones added: “These new figures reveal that hunts are continuing to flout the law whilst at the same time claiming they can police and control their hunters and supporters. It is time to end these cruel and barbaric activities and this can only be done by closing the loopholes in the Hunting Act. It was a Labour Party commitment in the 2024 manifesto and we need to action it now”.
The Government also hit out at the hunts. A Defra spokesperson said: “We are committed to enacting a ban on trail hunting that truly protects our countryside, wildlife and rural communities.
“The nature of trail hunting makes it difficult to ensure that wild mammals such as foxes, deer and hares are not placed in danger of being injured or killed by dogs and this must stop."
There is a need for more legislation to close these loopholes.
The paper says that despite a ban on fox hunting, new figures reveal 104 foxes were chased by hunts during fox cub hunting season:
Cub hunting takes place between August and the end of October and sees hunts surrounding fox habitats and setting their hounds on them to train the dogs how to hunt and kill.
Compiled by animal welfare charity the League Against Cruel Sports, the figures come from incidents reported into its confidential Animal Crimewatch service, evidence obtained by its field operatives, and from reports by hunt saboteurs and hunt monitors.
As well as the hunting of foxes, the data also showed 332 reports of hunts wreaking havoc with anti-social behaviour. The figures are only from hunts being monitored, meaning the true figure of foxes hunted could be even higher.
Emma Slawinski, chief executive of the League Against Cruel Sports, said: “The brutal practice of cub hunting is still happening despite the fox hunting ban and we need stronger hunting laws to end it once and for all.
“We need the government to act upon its pledge to ban so-called trail hunting and finish the job by introducing legislation in the next parliamentary session at the latest that will consign fox hunting to the history books.
“We also need an effective deterrent in the form of tougher penalties, the removal of all the loopholes in the Hunting Act, and the law changed so that hunts cannot claim their kills are ‘accidental’.”
Labour MP Ruth Jones added: “These new figures reveal that hunts are continuing to flout the law whilst at the same time claiming they can police and control their hunters and supporters. It is time to end these cruel and barbaric activities and this can only be done by closing the loopholes in the Hunting Act. It was a Labour Party commitment in the 2024 manifesto and we need to action it now”.
The Government also hit out at the hunts. A Defra spokesperson said: “We are committed to enacting a ban on trail hunting that truly protects our countryside, wildlife and rural communities.
“The nature of trail hunting makes it difficult to ensure that wild mammals such as foxes, deer and hares are not placed in danger of being injured or killed by dogs and this must stop."
There is a need for more legislation to close these loopholes.
Sunday, November 15, 2026
Reform UK and the rather damp free speech debate
The decision by the Senedd's presiding officer to block Reform UK's Joe Martin from speaking in the chamber until he apologises for trying to goad a minister with offensive and racist remarks, has generated a huge amount of heat in the media and on socials, though not much light.
As the BBC report, Reform UK have partially boycotted the Senedd in protest against the ban.
Their Welsh leader has claimed that the freedom of speech of one of her Senedd members is "being curtailed, meaning his constituents are being silenced."
As the BBC report, Reform UK have partially boycotted the Senedd in protest against the ban.
Their Welsh leader has claimed that the freedom of speech of one of her Senedd members is "being curtailed, meaning his constituents are being silenced."
Martin represents one of the most diverse constituencies in Wales, the vast majority of whose population would have no truck with the nonsense that he is spouting in claiming that white people are being replaced.
All sorts of right wingers have crawled out of the woodwork to have their say on this controversy, claiming to be standing for basic rights, even suggesting that Martin would not be penalised if he said the same outside the chamber. I suppose that would depend on where he said it and in what context, as in some instances it could be considered to be inflammatory language.
What is particularly galling is that many of these so-called commentators are trying to justify Martin's words on the basis that they are factual. However, as Aliya Mohammed, chief executive of the charity Race Equality First, says: "the idea that white people are being 'replaced' is linked to a conspiracy theory that creates division and wrongly portrays people from minority ethnic backgrounds as a threat". He continued:
"Immigration can and should be debated, but language that fuels fear and hostility has no place in public discourse," she said.
"Being Welsh or British is not defined by race or skin colour.
"Wales belongs to all of us, and our diversity is one of our greatest strengths."
Just to be clear, the "Great Replacement" theory (also called race replacement theory) is a debunked white nationalist conspiracy theory that falsely claims Western elites are secretly orchestrating the replacement of white populations with non-white immigrants.
All sorts of right wingers have crawled out of the woodwork to have their say on this controversy, claiming to be standing for basic rights, even suggesting that Martin would not be penalised if he said the same outside the chamber. I suppose that would depend on where he said it and in what context, as in some instances it could be considered to be inflammatory language.
What is particularly galling is that many of these so-called commentators are trying to justify Martin's words on the basis that they are factual. However, as Aliya Mohammed, chief executive of the charity Race Equality First, says: "the idea that white people are being 'replaced' is linked to a conspiracy theory that creates division and wrongly portrays people from minority ethnic backgrounds as a threat". He continued:
"Immigration can and should be debated, but language that fuels fear and hostility has no place in public discourse," she said.
"Being Welsh or British is not defined by race or skin colour.
"Wales belongs to all of us, and our diversity is one of our greatest strengths."
Just to be clear, the "Great Replacement" theory (also called race replacement theory) is a debunked white nationalist conspiracy theory that falsely claims Western elites are secretly orchestrating the replacement of white populations with non-white immigrants.
Demographers, historians, and economists consistently refute this narrative because it misinterprets natural population trends, ignores economic realities, and relies on fabricated claims of an intentional plot.
But what about the free speech argument? Surely, Martin should be able to speak freely, or should he?
The fact is that as a Parliamentarian and a community leader, Martin has a duty to act responsibly. There are rules and a code of conduct that he voluntarily signed up to when he took his seat. If he breaks those rules then he has to accept the consequences. There is no point moaning about it afterwards.
And those at the top of his party who are backing him in this, many of which have signed up to the same code of conduct, should know better. They don't appear to be interested in doing their job of effectively scrutinising the government. Instead, their sole interest seems to be stirring up a storm so they can play to their base.
Yet again these are tactics reminiscent of 1930s Germany. We should not be surprised at that.
But what about the free speech argument? Surely, Martin should be able to speak freely, or should he?
The fact is that as a Parliamentarian and a community leader, Martin has a duty to act responsibly. There are rules and a code of conduct that he voluntarily signed up to when he took his seat. If he breaks those rules then he has to accept the consequences. There is no point moaning about it afterwards.
And those at the top of his party who are backing him in this, many of which have signed up to the same code of conduct, should know better. They don't appear to be interested in doing their job of effectively scrutinising the government. Instead, their sole interest seems to be stirring up a storm so they can play to their base.
Yet again these are tactics reminiscent of 1930s Germany. We should not be surprised at that.
Saturday, November 14, 2026
A magnificent Norman Abbey
Margam Abbey was a Cistercian monastery, located in the village of Margam, a suburb of modern Port Talbot in Wales. The nave of the abbey church is still in use as the church of St Mary in the Church in Wales.
Wikipedia records that the abbey was founded in 1147 as a daughter house of Clairvaux by Robert, Earl of Gloucester, and was dedicated to the Blessed Virgin Mary. They say that early Christian crosses found in the close vicinity and conserved in the nearby Margam Stones Museum suggest the existence of an earlier Celtic monastic community:
The abbey was dissolved by King Henry VIII of England in 1536 and sold to Sir Rice Mansel. Significant holdings of the monastery library appear to have survived this event, including the manuscript of the annals. At this time, only 12 monks were living in the monastery.
From the Mansel family the abbey eventually passed to their descendants in the female line, the Talbot family. In the 19th century, C R M Talbot constructed a mansion at Margam Castle which overlooks the abbey ruins. The nave of the abbey continued in use as the parish church, as it does to this day. It is Anglo-Catholic in its churchmanship.
Margam Abbey now consists of the intact nave and surrounding ruins. Those ruins not belonging to the church are now owned by the County Council. These remains, including the twelve-sided chapter house, dating from the 13th century, stand within 840 acre (3.4 km2) Margam Country Park, close to Margam Castle. The Abbey church of St Mary, the ruined Chapter House and the Abbey undercroft are all Grade I listed buildings.
On a hill overlooking the abbey stand the ruins of an outlying monastery building, Capel Mair ar y Bryn ("the chapel of St Mary on the hill"). The purpose of this building is thought to have been to allow members of the monastic community who were engaged in the keeping of flocks to fulfil their devotional obligations without having to return to the main church.
The church is well worth a visit.
Wikipedia records that the abbey was founded in 1147 as a daughter house of Clairvaux by Robert, Earl of Gloucester, and was dedicated to the Blessed Virgin Mary. They say that early Christian crosses found in the close vicinity and conserved in the nearby Margam Stones Museum suggest the existence of an earlier Celtic monastic community:
The abbey was dissolved by King Henry VIII of England in 1536 and sold to Sir Rice Mansel. Significant holdings of the monastery library appear to have survived this event, including the manuscript of the annals. At this time, only 12 monks were living in the monastery.
From the Mansel family the abbey eventually passed to their descendants in the female line, the Talbot family. In the 19th century, C R M Talbot constructed a mansion at Margam Castle which overlooks the abbey ruins. The nave of the abbey continued in use as the parish church, as it does to this day. It is Anglo-Catholic in its churchmanship.
Margam Abbey now consists of the intact nave and surrounding ruins. Those ruins not belonging to the church are now owned by the County Council. These remains, including the twelve-sided chapter house, dating from the 13th century, stand within 840 acre (3.4 km2) Margam Country Park, close to Margam Castle. The Abbey church of St Mary, the ruined Chapter House and the Abbey undercroft are all Grade I listed buildings.
On a hill overlooking the abbey stand the ruins of an outlying monastery building, Capel Mair ar y Bryn ("the chapel of St Mary on the hill"). The purpose of this building is thought to have been to allow members of the monastic community who were engaged in the keeping of flocks to fulfil their devotional obligations without having to return to the main church.
The church is well worth a visit.
Labels: lochist
Friday, November 13, 2026
An extended period of silence is called for
The last person I and many others want to hear from on Brexit and the EU is David Cameron. The man who bumbled and fumbled the UK's economic and political future for short term political goals and then walked away from the consequences of his actions does not deserve a say on what happens now.
However, it seems that the man doesn't know when to shut up. The Independent reports that the former prime minister has advised Andy Burnham against starting a "decade-long debate" over whether to rejoin the European Union. Presumably, he is happy for the country to spend another decade continuing to suffer the debilitating consequences of the Brexit he is responsible for.
As the paper says Burnham has reignited discussion regarding Britain’s future relationship with the EU. They add that he is due to meet EU leaders in Brussels next week to sign agreements he claims could boost GDP by 0.4% – covering agriculture, emissions trading and a youth mobility scheme:
Following the summit, the UK will "explore options" for a different long-term relationship with the bloc.
His recent remarks have raised questions about the UK returning to the EU or adopting freedom of movement rules, though the Prime Minister insisted voters would be "the boss" of changes.
Lord Cameron told Bloomberg he was "desperately disappointed" when the UK voted to leave the EU 10 years ago, but he warned against attempting to reverse the decision.
"Instead of launching an argument about rejoining, which I think would be a very long and painful argument – and who knows where it would end up – instead of that, focus on how do we be the best friend, best neighbour, best partner," he said.
He said "flirting with rejoining" could hamper efforts to get a better deal, because EU countries might feel there is no point if the UK rejoins anyway.
"If you’re not going to, you know, commit to trying to make the partnership stronger because you’re flirting with rejoining, I think there’s some dangers there," he said.
He appeared lukewarm on rejoining a customs union, saying economic problems are not down to Brexit.
"Our economic problems are we are overspending, over-borrowing, over-taxing, over-regulated, and far too much being spent on working age welfare. Those are a set of problems that have nothing to do with Brexit," he said.
"Do we really want to go into another decade-long debate about whether we should be in or out, when actually we should deal with our own problems while making the partnership model work?"
Despite all that has happened, despite the huge cost to our economy and society of us leaving the EU, Cameron is as clueless as ever. An extended period of silence from him would be appreciated by many of us.
However, it seems that the man doesn't know when to shut up. The Independent reports that the former prime minister has advised Andy Burnham against starting a "decade-long debate" over whether to rejoin the European Union. Presumably, he is happy for the country to spend another decade continuing to suffer the debilitating consequences of the Brexit he is responsible for.
As the paper says Burnham has reignited discussion regarding Britain’s future relationship with the EU. They add that he is due to meet EU leaders in Brussels next week to sign agreements he claims could boost GDP by 0.4% – covering agriculture, emissions trading and a youth mobility scheme:
Following the summit, the UK will "explore options" for a different long-term relationship with the bloc.
His recent remarks have raised questions about the UK returning to the EU or adopting freedom of movement rules, though the Prime Minister insisted voters would be "the boss" of changes.
Lord Cameron told Bloomberg he was "desperately disappointed" when the UK voted to leave the EU 10 years ago, but he warned against attempting to reverse the decision.
"Instead of launching an argument about rejoining, which I think would be a very long and painful argument – and who knows where it would end up – instead of that, focus on how do we be the best friend, best neighbour, best partner," he said.
He said "flirting with rejoining" could hamper efforts to get a better deal, because EU countries might feel there is no point if the UK rejoins anyway.
"If you’re not going to, you know, commit to trying to make the partnership stronger because you’re flirting with rejoining, I think there’s some dangers there," he said.
He appeared lukewarm on rejoining a customs union, saying economic problems are not down to Brexit.
"Our economic problems are we are overspending, over-borrowing, over-taxing, over-regulated, and far too much being spent on working age welfare. Those are a set of problems that have nothing to do with Brexit," he said.
"Do we really want to go into another decade-long debate about whether we should be in or out, when actually we should deal with our own problems while making the partnership model work?"
Despite all that has happened, despite the huge cost to our economy and society of us leaving the EU, Cameron is as clueless as ever. An extended period of silence from him would be appreciated by many of us.
Thursday, November 12, 2026
The many contortions of Reform UK in Wales
The BBC reports that Reform UK's leader in Wales says she stands "firmly" by one of her Senedd members who was banned from speaking in the parliament for claiming white people are being "replaced" in the UK. This is a well-known and recognised white nationalist conspiracy theory, often associated with anti-Semitism:
The party's Welsh leader, Helen Jenner, said Joe Martin's ban was because of "undue pressure" from governing party Plaid Cymru and was an "infringement on freedom of speech".
Martin had been told he would not be allowed to speak in the Senedd's chamber until he apologised for the remarks, which the parliament's Presiding Officer Huw Irranca-Davies called "unnecessarily provocative and deliberately offensive".
Reform UK leader Nigel Farage called the ruling "ridiculous and outrageous".
Reform, which is by far the Senedd's largest opposition party, said its members would withdraw from most of Wednesday's proceedings before returning to vote in the parliament later in the evening.
Joe Martin was also backed by the leader of right-wing party Restore Britain, Rupert Lowe.
The controversial question by Martin is just the latest in a series of disruptive tactics by Reform UK. Will Hayward's substack is very informative on this. He has carried out a deep-dive look inside the Reform UK group within the Welsh Parliament, speaking to Reform Senedd Members, staffers and figures from other parties, trawling committee attendances and looking inside WhatsApp groups:
What we have found is a party that:
* is failing to adequately scrutinise the Welsh Government and hold them to account
* has a culture of ‘mass paranoia’ and suspicion towards journalists, other parties and organisations
* is seemingly beset with infighting and hamstrung by excessive control from Nigel Farage and the UK-wide Reform party
We approached all Reform MSs giving them an opportunity to speak to us for this piece. Those who agreed did so under the strict promise of anonymity.
As you read this, it’s important to bear in mind this is not a party on the fringes of Welsh politics. They are the official opposition, a vital cog in a functioning Welsh democracy. They are apparently, to use their words, “preparing for Government in 2030”.
Will Hayward points out that far from taking their job of scrutiny seriously, that out of exactly 100 Senedd committee meetings held between May 8th and October 21st, there have been 31 times when at least one Reform MS has been absent. That is almost a third of all meetings, almost as many meetings as all the other parties’ MSs put together.
Reform UK also claim to have made 2,300 speeches in the Senedd, Will Hayward has counted 2,318 in both committee and the Senedd plenary, however, some of those 'speeches amount to just a single word. Furthermore,
Martin had been told he would not be allowed to speak in the Senedd's chamber until he apologised for the remarks, which the parliament's Presiding Officer Huw Irranca-Davies called "unnecessarily provocative and deliberately offensive".
Reform UK leader Nigel Farage called the ruling "ridiculous and outrageous".
Reform, which is by far the Senedd's largest opposition party, said its members would withdraw from most of Wednesday's proceedings before returning to vote in the parliament later in the evening.
Joe Martin was also backed by the leader of right-wing party Restore Britain, Rupert Lowe.
The controversial question by Martin is just the latest in a series of disruptive tactics by Reform UK. Will Hayward's substack is very informative on this. He has carried out a deep-dive look inside the Reform UK group within the Welsh Parliament, speaking to Reform Senedd Members, staffers and figures from other parties, trawling committee attendances and looking inside WhatsApp groups:
What we have found is a party that:
* is failing to adequately scrutinise the Welsh Government and hold them to account
* has a culture of ‘mass paranoia’ and suspicion towards journalists, other parties and organisations
* is seemingly beset with infighting and hamstrung by excessive control from Nigel Farage and the UK-wide Reform party
We approached all Reform MSs giving them an opportunity to speak to us for this piece. Those who agreed did so under the strict promise of anonymity.
As you read this, it’s important to bear in mind this is not a party on the fringes of Welsh politics. They are the official opposition, a vital cog in a functioning Welsh democracy. They are apparently, to use their words, “preparing for Government in 2030”.
Will Hayward points out that far from taking their job of scrutiny seriously, that out of exactly 100 Senedd committee meetings held between May 8th and October 21st, there have been 31 times when at least one Reform MS has been absent. That is almost a third of all meetings, almost as many meetings as all the other parties’ MSs put together.
Reform UK also claim to have made 2,300 speeches in the Senedd, Will Hayward has counted 2,318 in both committee and the Senedd plenary, however, some of those 'speeches amount to just a single word. Furthermore,
Reform UK's Deputy Leader, Laura Anne Jones’ claims of taking their “job to scrutinise seriously” also ring a little hollow when just last week she won a ballot to lead a short debate in the Senedd but did not notify the Table Office of her selected topic by the deadline:
In Reform’s defence, they have seemingly managed to…erm…hold themselves to account.
On June 11, a third of the party bizarrely voted in favour of a motion criticising their own Senedd election manifesto for having no commitments on childcare.
This hardly paints the picture of a party prepared to do the hard graft of scrutiny, holding ministers to account or “preparing for government” in 2030.
But it is Reform UK's paranoia that really stands out for Will Hayward. He quotes an incident when a Reform MS sat at his table in the Senedd canteen only to flee when he realised that he was sharing the space with a journalist, telling him: “I am not allowed to be here or talk to you.”
Hayward describes this episode as the perfect embodiment of the culture within the Reform group:
Absolute paranoia of the media, opposition parties and perhaps most of all, each other.
Reform MS Francesca O’Brien even raised the issue in the Senedd (presumably this was one of their 2,300 speeches) where she asked for journalists’ access to be restricted because someone was “chatty” to her in a toilet.
But it isn’t just journalists that are off limits for conversation. As one MS told us:
“Before the election we were told not to speak to the media at all. But it was also organisations. Anyone who upset HQ got onto the list.
“This included Cavendish, Oxfam, Shelter Cymru, Nation Cymru, you, Books Trust, the Future Generations Commissioner and the Children’s Commissioner.
“The reason for Shelter was because they were critical of Reform’s immigration and asylum policy, and HQ couldn’t handle the fact that they were being criticised.
“It has also been made clear to us that speaking to journalists who are banned would be a very serious matter.”
It is genuinely astounding how deep the worry of incurring the wrath of those higher up goes within Reform. The conversations we had with MSs all had to take place away from the Senedd or over the phone for fear of retribution.
Perhaps this is understandable given the dictatorial nature of the party structure, with HQ in London keeping a very tight grip on the Welsh part of the party (we will come on to this later).
The perceived power of those higher up is omnipresent. In the Reform Senedd group office there is a massive 6ft poster of Nigel Farage, who is widely referred to by the moniker “The Big Boss” by the Welsh group.
As one figure told us:
“It was decided that we’re going to have it [the poster] in the office, but some people were embarrassed, unsurprisingly. They decided to have it on the back of the main door. So as you look into the office you can’t see it but as you leave it is staring at you.”
While there is a fear of journalists and outside organisations, what about other parties?
Several people with Reform described the situation as “mass paranoia”. One told us “if some was to speak to another party” they would be considered a “defection risk”.
But who is calling the shots for Reform UK in Wales? Will Hayward has an interesting insight:
Part of the challenge for both Mr Thomas and his successor Helen Jenner is that they don’t have any real autonomy from the wider Reform group. The nature of the Senedd is that coalitions or alliances are almost inevitable. But the Welsh Reform constitution, seen by this newsletter, states that Nigel Farage must give permission for the Reform group to work with any other party.
It states that if Helen Jenner wishes to enter into any formal coalition or ongoing voting arrangement with any members of any other political party (including Independents) she must “seek advance approval from the Party Leader by way of a formal request in writing to the Party Leader”.
The constitution also states that it is the central party that is ultimately responsible for disciplining members.
Rather than issues being dealt with by Helen Jenner or Llyr Powell, when there is a perceived failure the likes of Matthew MacKinnon and Ed Sumner will be called in from London.
MacKinnon has bounced around jobs in both Reform and the Tories but now is the director of external affairs for Reform.
Sumner, who is Reform’s head of communications, used to work for Laura Anne Jones. He was filmed saying his job was “defending the indefensible” in a recent undercover ITV documentary. Leaked messages also show he once described me as a “c***” (though in my view that credits him as a good judge of character).
One figure in the group told us:
“You can see their worldview is that we [in Wales] actually need a parent to come in and take care of things.”
Another Reform figure was less generous about MacKinnon and Sumner:
“Those two are just awful. They are dictators who don’t actually have any ideas on how to improve things.”
Because Reform are boycotting the Senedd on Armistice Day. this means that the official opposition won't be taking part in a debate they tabled on how we can better support the armed forces and veterans.
In Reform’s defence, they have seemingly managed to…erm…hold themselves to account.
On June 11, a third of the party bizarrely voted in favour of a motion criticising their own Senedd election manifesto for having no commitments on childcare.
This hardly paints the picture of a party prepared to do the hard graft of scrutiny, holding ministers to account or “preparing for government” in 2030.
But it is Reform UK's paranoia that really stands out for Will Hayward. He quotes an incident when a Reform MS sat at his table in the Senedd canteen only to flee when he realised that he was sharing the space with a journalist, telling him: “I am not allowed to be here or talk to you.”
Hayward describes this episode as the perfect embodiment of the culture within the Reform group:
Absolute paranoia of the media, opposition parties and perhaps most of all, each other.
Reform MS Francesca O’Brien even raised the issue in the Senedd (presumably this was one of their 2,300 speeches) where she asked for journalists’ access to be restricted because someone was “chatty” to her in a toilet.
But it isn’t just journalists that are off limits for conversation. As one MS told us:
“Before the election we were told not to speak to the media at all. But it was also organisations. Anyone who upset HQ got onto the list.
“This included Cavendish, Oxfam, Shelter Cymru, Nation Cymru, you, Books Trust, the Future Generations Commissioner and the Children’s Commissioner.
“The reason for Shelter was because they were critical of Reform’s immigration and asylum policy, and HQ couldn’t handle the fact that they were being criticised.
“It has also been made clear to us that speaking to journalists who are banned would be a very serious matter.”
It is genuinely astounding how deep the worry of incurring the wrath of those higher up goes within Reform. The conversations we had with MSs all had to take place away from the Senedd or over the phone for fear of retribution.
Perhaps this is understandable given the dictatorial nature of the party structure, with HQ in London keeping a very tight grip on the Welsh part of the party (we will come on to this later).
The perceived power of those higher up is omnipresent. In the Reform Senedd group office there is a massive 6ft poster of Nigel Farage, who is widely referred to by the moniker “The Big Boss” by the Welsh group.
As one figure told us:
“It was decided that we’re going to have it [the poster] in the office, but some people were embarrassed, unsurprisingly. They decided to have it on the back of the main door. So as you look into the office you can’t see it but as you leave it is staring at you.”
While there is a fear of journalists and outside organisations, what about other parties?
Several people with Reform described the situation as “mass paranoia”. One told us “if some was to speak to another party” they would be considered a “defection risk”.
But who is calling the shots for Reform UK in Wales? Will Hayward has an interesting insight:
Part of the challenge for both Mr Thomas and his successor Helen Jenner is that they don’t have any real autonomy from the wider Reform group. The nature of the Senedd is that coalitions or alliances are almost inevitable. But the Welsh Reform constitution, seen by this newsletter, states that Nigel Farage must give permission for the Reform group to work with any other party.
It states that if Helen Jenner wishes to enter into any formal coalition or ongoing voting arrangement with any members of any other political party (including Independents) she must “seek advance approval from the Party Leader by way of a formal request in writing to the Party Leader”.
The constitution also states that it is the central party that is ultimately responsible for disciplining members.
Rather than issues being dealt with by Helen Jenner or Llyr Powell, when there is a perceived failure the likes of Matthew MacKinnon and Ed Sumner will be called in from London.
MacKinnon has bounced around jobs in both Reform and the Tories but now is the director of external affairs for Reform.
Sumner, who is Reform’s head of communications, used to work for Laura Anne Jones. He was filmed saying his job was “defending the indefensible” in a recent undercover ITV documentary. Leaked messages also show he once described me as a “c***” (though in my view that credits him as a good judge of character).
One figure in the group told us:
“You can see their worldview is that we [in Wales] actually need a parent to come in and take care of things.”
Another Reform figure was less generous about MacKinnon and Sumner:
“Those two are just awful. They are dictators who don’t actually have any ideas on how to improve things.”
Because Reform are boycotting the Senedd on Armistice Day. this means that the official opposition won't be taking part in a debate they tabled on how we can better support the armed forces and veterans.
Wednesday, November 11, 2026
Plaid Cymru pursue their independence obsession at taxpayer's expense
During the Senedd election the now-First Minister said that his first goal was to show people what a Plaid government can do. Yet rather than focus on the key issues of health, education, and the cost of living, it seems that they are still obsessed with independence, and it is the taxpayers who are picking up the bill.
The BBC reports that the case for Welsh independence, as well as more devolution for Cardiff Bay, will be considered by a new body set-up by the Plaid Cymru Welsh government.
The news website says that the so-called National Commission for Wales will provide "advice, evidence and analysis" on the country's constitutional future, at a cost "in the ballpark" of £500,000 a year.
Although Plaid Cymru made a manifesto pledge to establish the commission at the May election and ruled out trying to hold an independence referendum this term, they have also suggested that if re-elected they may make the case for independence in a white paper:
It is not the first commission that has looked at the powers of Wales' devolved bodies - previous exercises included the Silk commission of the early 2010s, a commission on how justice operates which published in 2019, and a commission in 2024 which concluded that independence was a viable option.
The latter work said outside of the UK Wales would face a "significant" short to medium term challenge raising enough tax revenue for public services.
It is not clear when the commission would report. The constitution minister said it would also look at the responsibilities of local government.
The Welsh government is coming under pressure from Andy Burnham's Labour Westminster administration to devolve more to the regions of Wales.
The new commission would not exclusively examine the prospect of Wales being a sovereign state, but it would be one of three "viable options" considered.
These also include enhanced devolution and a federal United Kingdom - the idea of a UK where each home nation has much more power over their own affairs while Westminster retains overall powers on things matters such as defence.
According to the Welsh government, the "independent standing body" will provide "independent advice on devolution priorities, including areas such as the "Crown Estate, rail infrastructure, justice and policing".
The Welsh government is pressing Westminster for all four to be devolved to the Senedd and Welsh ministers.
The Welsh government said the commission will talk to people from across Wales, and would conduct research "on key political, economic and democratic questions relevant to Wales' future".
We have had decades of commissions and investigations, and here we are again. At the same time the Welsh health service is in crisis, educationally Wales is at the bottom of pile when it comes to literacy and numeracy, our economy is still struggling and proposals to help people in lower council tax bands by revaluing have been shelved. Plaid's priorities are all wrong.
The BBC reports that the case for Welsh independence, as well as more devolution for Cardiff Bay, will be considered by a new body set-up by the Plaid Cymru Welsh government.
The news website says that the so-called National Commission for Wales will provide "advice, evidence and analysis" on the country's constitutional future, at a cost "in the ballpark" of £500,000 a year.
Although Plaid Cymru made a manifesto pledge to establish the commission at the May election and ruled out trying to hold an independence referendum this term, they have also suggested that if re-elected they may make the case for independence in a white paper:
It is not the first commission that has looked at the powers of Wales' devolved bodies - previous exercises included the Silk commission of the early 2010s, a commission on how justice operates which published in 2019, and a commission in 2024 which concluded that independence was a viable option.
The latter work said outside of the UK Wales would face a "significant" short to medium term challenge raising enough tax revenue for public services.
It is not clear when the commission would report. The constitution minister said it would also look at the responsibilities of local government.
The Welsh government is coming under pressure from Andy Burnham's Labour Westminster administration to devolve more to the regions of Wales.
The new commission would not exclusively examine the prospect of Wales being a sovereign state, but it would be one of three "viable options" considered.
These also include enhanced devolution and a federal United Kingdom - the idea of a UK where each home nation has much more power over their own affairs while Westminster retains overall powers on things matters such as defence.
According to the Welsh government, the "independent standing body" will provide "independent advice on devolution priorities, including areas such as the "Crown Estate, rail infrastructure, justice and policing".
The Welsh government is pressing Westminster for all four to be devolved to the Senedd and Welsh ministers.
The Welsh government said the commission will talk to people from across Wales, and would conduct research "on key political, economic and democratic questions relevant to Wales' future".
We have had decades of commissions and investigations, and here we are again. At the same time the Welsh health service is in crisis, educationally Wales is at the bottom of pile when it comes to literacy and numeracy, our economy is still struggling and proposals to help people in lower council tax bands by revaluing have been shelved. Plaid's priorities are all wrong.














